Isaac,+Matt+L.,+Tim,+Troy+-+The+Watchmen

Its great book and a phenomenal experience to be able to read a comic book(Graphic Novel) in college credit class. The critics have said that this has been one of the most astonishing books they have ever come in contact with. This book has been called the "Romeo and Juliet" of it's time period by people who have read it. The book was brought to my attention my a highly respected member of the Pascack Valley community. The book is so spectacular that it is being made into to a movie that will be shown in theaters all over the world. I am more than fanatic about reading this book. I am counting down the days until the book is delivered and I can embark on my long and wonderful time I will have reading this book. So much has been said about //Watchmen //. Some call it the “Citizen Kane” of graphic novels. Others say the book is responsible for changing the face of modern comic books. To date, Watchmen remains the only graphic novel to win a Hugo Award, and is also the only graphic novel to appear on Time Magazine’s 2005 list of “the 100 best English-language novels from 1923 to the present.” Here is a list of some online analyses, essays, critiques, commentaries and reviews we have found on the Web.

From http://www.watchmencomicmovie.com/watchmen-analysis-criticism-reviews.php  __**APPROVED**__

A -Matt L Reporter (spelt isaac's name wrong) B -Isaac Group leader C -Troy food D - Tim Questions __**Questions

1. Who do think killed the comedian? 2. Where did john go after the interview? 3. Does John have cancer? Explain? 4. Do you think John will come back? 5. Why doesn’t anyone trust Rochambu?**__

__**Report**__

__**Comedian was murdered and that he suspects it’s part of a bigger plot to kill off other former heroes. Dreiberg tells Rorschach that he’s just being paranoid. At the end of the chapter they have a quote “At midnight, all the agents and superhuman crew go out and round up everyone who knows more than they do.” - Desolation Row by Bob Dylan. When Rorschach sees former costumed villain Moloch leaving Blake’s funeral, he questions him about The Comedian’s death. he questions him about The Comedian’s death Our meeting was very productive. We were able to answer all of the questions very successfully. It seemed as if everyone read. And when one of us we were unable to answer one of Tim’s very difficult questions we then informed. Even Morone chimed in to this fabulous discussion. We continue to enjoy the phenomenal story. I liked the question Tim asked about who we think killed comidian. We are a great group and we will continue to strive for success**__

__**By Matt Lind

Week 2 - Language

A -Matt Questions B -Tim Group leader C - Isaac Food D -Troy absent

Discussion Questions:**__ Why was jon waiting to die Who do you think killed Moloch’s Why were the prisoners threatening and mocking Kovacs What do you think will happen later on what will Rorschach find next The meeting went really well. We got alot of work done. We defitanely finished a lot more then last week. This might be cause im not going to say names cough troy was not here. Isaac brought in delicious brownies and we just ate them all up right when they came out. Isaac and matt had fought for the last brownie. Matt asked us the hardest questions i ever heard before. We got into a massive debate about who killed Moloch. Morone came over cause we were talking so loud about the book and joined in on our discussion. He didn't even know what to say.
 * Summary:

Week 3

Nuge - Food (nice zebra cakes) Troy - questions (not made) Matt - Leader (did a great job) Isaac - Reporter (sexy)

Summary: this week was great. The zebra cakes were amazing. the questions were mind bending and creative. there were no problems and we moved smoothly through the period. before we knew it the period was over and we were off to period 8.

Week 4

Troy- great leader Matt- food Isaac- questions Nuge- reporter

Questions:** Does learning Rorschach’s past change your view towards him?

What do you think is the best thing for Dr. Ostaman to do?

Do you feel bad from Dr. Ostaman for all he has gone through?

Would you want to become like him?

What is symbolic of Rorschach’s name and mask?

a lil bit late but everything was alright because he had a giant pie of pizza in his hands. I cant even say how delicious that pizza was. After that Isaac had told us his questions. We got into a huge fight about it and Troy kept the group in line. It was a great book club meeting and we moved on with our life.
 * Matt gave us a little scare when he didnt come in. He came in

Troy- Reporter Nuge- food Isaac- Questions Matt- Group Leader

This was a great way to end our book club meetings. Our assembly yesterday with the beloved Alphie Mchourty kinda threw off our rhythm. Nuge really pulled through with a last minute Domino's order. Lind and Isaac couldn't decide who was the group leader and who the quistionare was so they compromised and decided to split the roles. We had an excellent meeting and we will continue to work toward perfection.

How did you enjoy the graphic novel? Do you agree with Veidt? Why? What would you change to make this book better? In your opinion what was your favorite part of the book? Who was your favorite character? Why?**